Edgar Cayce Receives His Scholarly Context

 
Back
Up
Next

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The year 1998, that has figured so prominently in Edgar Cayce’s prophecies, has now gained added significance. It marks the initiation of his work into the mainstream. For one thing, during 1998 the A&E Network aired its Edgar Cayce biography on television. It was also the beginning of scholarly recognition of Edgar Cayce, something for which people have been waiting many years. The appearance of the book, Edgar Cayce in Context: The Readings: Truth and Fiction (State University of New York Press) by K. Paul Johnson, marks a turning point in the history of the Cayce story. It should be required reading of all A.R.E. members, who may then wish to discuss the mission statement of their organization, perhaps to include continuing the process that Johnson has started.

Written in a supportive style by a person partial to Cayce, Johnson’s scholarly evaluation of Cayce is educational, inspiring, and sobering. The author is a historian whose previous book, The Masters Revealed: Madame Blavatsky and the Myth of the Great White Lodge, was received with some acclaim. He discusses with historical perspective the main areas of Cayce’s contribution--holistic health, esoteric Christianity, spiritual psychology, and far history. There are some specific claims put forth by Cayce that have been, or can at some time be, validated or invalidated, and Mr. Johnson compiles this information--that’s the "truth or fiction" part of the book. It probably doesn’t contain enough of the former to satisfy "Cayce believers." The other part of the book, the "context," has really made me think about what it means to be a "Cayce believer" and what a "believer" can reasonably expect, or hope for, relative to those beliefs, from a scholarly evaluation of Cayce’s work. Belief in the man competes for attention with belief in the ideas he championed--that tension seems to be part of the history of the Cayce story.

It is in the nature of the scientific enterprise to quibble with any assertion. Certainly the assertion that Edgar Cayce was a psychic is a target for quibbling, especially to people who doubt the reality of ESP. The assertion that Cayce was creative, bringing forth new ideas that had made no previous appearance in history, is also subject to doubt. Any assertion that a particular medical treatment that Cayce might have suggested is an effective treatment, or that it’s efficacy proves the validity of Cayce’s assertions about the principles of health and illness, these are also easy targets for skepticism. Unfortunately, most of these assertions are easier to doubt than to prove. Johnson does what he can with the facts at hand, but his efforts instead prove the difficulty of evaluating the most popular assertions made about Cayce.

Perhaps more constructive is his attempt to link the ideas that Cayce articulated with the history of ideas. In the classic Cayce biography, There is a River, Thomas Sugrue introduces Cayce’s story as a "chapter in the history of hypnosis." We see how Cayce responded to the opportunity that transpersonal hypnosis provides. That perspective has the advantage of stimulating others to see what they can accomplish through hypnosis, an endeavor that Cayce himself encouraged. In Johnson’s treatment, Cayce’s story is placed within the context of theosophy ("a gnosis that has bearing, not only on the salvific relations the individual maintains with the divine world, but also on the nature of God Himself, or of divine persons, and on the natural universe, the origin of that universe, the hidden structures that constitute it in its actual state, its relationship to mankind, and its final ends," to quote Antoine Faivre, the leading academic scholar of esoteric spirituality). The author identifies Cayce as "the premier Christian theosopher of the twentieth century in the English speaking world."

What Cayce brought forward from his transpersonal hypnotic state has been an innovative theosophy, probably the most influential we’ve had, and which bridged the older theosophies with the modern "New Age" thinking. Cayce’s linking of spirituality with psychological processes, and the state of the physical health with the condition of the psyche, makes his a particularly practical spirituality. These are facts that the author realizes and reflects in his analysis.

In painting the larger picture, the history of human thought and experimentation relative to the question of divine/human interaction as it manifests in human experience, Johnson’s book suggests that such seminal figures as Edgar Cayce and Carl Jung have inspired us to re-evaluate our self-image and recognize our potential as companion co-creators with the life force. Although it is human nature to hero worship an inspiring role model, there comes a time when we have to recognize the hero within. No amount of amazing feats by Mr. Cayce, even validated by science or scholarship, will substitute for our own efforts to bring forth our own versions of enlightenment. Such efforts will be the validation of his work that I believe Mr. Cayce most cherished.

Just Surfing the Book Columns?
Try These Links:
Read Next Article
Read Previous One

Buy Edgar Cayce in Context: The Readings: Truth and Fiction now!

 

   

Back | Up | Next | Email

This page was last updated 04/28/02